"How do you not fall into the 'all God's Creatures' category?"

The other day we were doing the grace after meals and came to the part in the first benediction about how God provides food for all his creatures.

When Alligator or UGA is doing grace after meal with us they get very excited at this point and jump up and down. But that day we had the stuffed pumpkin farmer. It seemed to me that he didn't fit into this category because he is a composite of two things that do exist, pumpkins and farmers but the composite doesn't actually exist (except for the stuffed animal).